Over the next two weeks you are going to have an opportunity as groups to learn about two technologies so you can write wiki pages about them. Part of the reason why we created this assignment was so you could see the breadth of technologies available for your specific discipline after it was all done, and so you could have the opportunity to learn a new technology.
I've seen some groups plan to do wiki pages on the Internet, movies, even magnets. Yes, these are all technologies -- but everybody already knows about them! The wiki is meant to be a collection of descriptions about technologies that aren't as well known ... so that we can teach other and give each other new ideas.
I STRONGLY suggest that when you're deciding what wiki pages to do as a group, that you don't do something easy or lame like the Internet. Talk as a group about what technologies are used in your field, technologies that maybe you don't know very well but would like to. Then you can study these technologies as you write wiki pages about them. If you have no clue what technologies might be good for your field of study, then ask your professors, practicing teachers, etc. As a last resort, you can brainstorm with me. I can maybe offer some ideas, but I'm not going to know your specific field of study as well as your professors would.
Have fun! And be bold and branch out--let's explore some technologies that may be unfamiliar!
Thursday, September 23, 2004
Is blogging helping or hurting?
Jared brings up a good question on his blog about computer-supported collaborative learning (CSCL). He specifically is talking about CSCL, but others have made the same argument about other forms of CSCL, such as discussion boards, instant messenging, even email. He said:
I responded to Jared by saying:
I'd like to hear from some of the rest of you about this. People make a similar argument about what technology may or may not be doing to our writing. Some people say it makes us worse writers because we get lazy and use spell checker instead of really learning to spell, and we use weird internet lingo like "R U going 2 go?". Others argue that technology is helping us become better writers, or at least more frequent writers, because EVERYBODY seems to be emailing, instant messenging or blogging these days, whereas they used to not do any writing at all unless for school.
So back to the original point Jared brought up: Is technology helping or hindering?
"Now don't get me wrong. I have really enjoyed my blogging experience. But I can't help but question, in a classroom setting, does blogging unify the class, or separate it? Let me qualify that question. We are in an age where communication is easier than it has ever been. We can follow the news in myriad mediums. We can send and recieve emails rather than wait for days or months to receive snail mail. But it seems to me that technology leads to a downgrade in communication rather than an upgrade. We spend time every week sitting at a computer communicating in writing precisely so we don't have to sit down in person with people who walk around all day on our same campus! We say, "isn't this convenient that I can get all the benefits of talking to Danielle without ever really having to talk to Danielle?" ... It seems that technology is doing more to separate us from the world and from eachother than it is doing to unite us."
I responded to Jared by saying:
"Really good comment, Jared. This debate is hot in educational technology research right now. Some people argue that technology increases collaboration and interaction, some argue it doesn't. I think a key is, does the computer-supported collaboration replace face-to-face interaction? If so, then it might not be a good choice. However, does it add interaction that wouldn't be there otherwise? For example, if the choice was no interaction because we don't have time (or whatever our excuse is), or interaction through the Internet, which is better?
Another example, I'm interacting with teachers from Australia and England right now on a project. They met me through my blog, and we are collaborating by working together on a wiki, discussion board, and through email to accomplish a project. I'd never talk to these people for real, so being able to communicate through the Internet is helpful. But I agree that emailing my wife or close friends here at BYU is less effective than actually talking to them."
I'd like to hear from some of the rest of you about this. People make a similar argument about what technology may or may not be doing to our writing. Some people say it makes us worse writers because we get lazy and use spell checker instead of really learning to spell, and we use weird internet lingo like "R U going 2 go?". Others argue that technology is helping us become better writers, or at least more frequent writers, because EVERYBODY seems to be emailing, instant messenging or blogging these days, whereas they used to not do any writing at all unless for school.
So back to the original point Jared brought up: Is technology helping or hindering?
Reminder on the blogrolls assignment
Memory wrote to me this about the blogrolls assignment:
"For some reason the Blogrolls (and a few of the other links) link on the assignment page isn't working. I tried to check the rubric to make sure I had completed all of the requirements for the assignment, but I couldn't get to it! (It was working in class, so I'm not sure what has changed.)"
I've fixed that now, so it should work--thanks Memory!
By the way, I checked the assignment and remembered that part of the assignment is to also put your blogging buddies' blog URLs on your blogroll. This should be a snap, because once you've figured out how to put a link in a blogroll, it's not hard to just put a few more. Just copy the code, and change the URL. Anyway, we did this so that if me or Alyssa ever go to your blog, we'll be able to easily know who else is in your blogging group and we could go to their blogs easily because they will be linked to yours.
SO DON'T FORGET TO ADD YOUR BLOGGING BUDDIES TO YOUR BLOGROLL!
In case you need it, here's the link to the blogroll tutorial again.
"For some reason the Blogrolls (and a few of the other links) link on the assignment page isn't working. I tried to check the rubric to make sure I had completed all of the requirements for the assignment, but I couldn't get to it! (It was working in class, so I'm not sure what has changed.)"
I've fixed that now, so it should work--thanks Memory!
By the way, I checked the assignment and remembered that part of the assignment is to also put your blogging buddies' blog URLs on your blogroll. This should be a snap, because once you've figured out how to put a link in a blogroll, it's not hard to just put a few more. Just copy the code, and change the URL. Anyway, we did this so that if me or Alyssa ever go to your blog, we'll be able to easily know who else is in your blogging group and we could go to their blogs easily because they will be linked to yours.
SO DON'T FORGET TO ADD YOUR BLOGGING BUDDIES TO YOUR BLOGROLL!
In case you need it, here's the link to the blogroll tutorial again.
Wednesday, September 22, 2004
Answering some questions
I met with a few students yesterday, and thought I might answer a few questions that they had here on my blog in case anyone else had the same question.
Remember that each group does two wiki pages -- and ALL members of the group work on each page. You only have to outline what you want to do this week. You actually make the wiki pages next week. For these page, you can do 2 description pages (describing a technology, like Inspiration) or two integration pages (describing how to use Inspiration in a class), or one of each.
Some students worried that all the pages were taken up for what they wanted to do. To clarify, only one group can do a description page on a technology. For example, if someone else is explaining Excel, what it is, and so forth--why would you want to do that? There's only so much you can say. However, there are hundreds of different ways to apply Excel to school situations. So there could be hundreds of Excel Integration pages. If someone is already doing an Excel integration page, and you want to, just make a new link to a new page and do it!
Remember that if you don't understand wikis (for example, you don't know what I was talking about when I said, "make a new page"), then go to the wiki sandbox and learn! Here's the link to the sandbox: http://ipt.byu.edu/~wiki/28x/Main/WikiSandbox
Go there and at the bottom of the screen are some brief directions on how to write and create in wiki. I'll give only one tip here. If, when you're typing, you mash two words together, like this: "RickWest," it will create a new page and link to that page. It's that easy!
Remember that each group does two wiki pages -- and ALL members of the group work on each page. You only have to outline what you want to do this week. You actually make the wiki pages next week. For these page, you can do 2 description pages (describing a technology, like Inspiration) or two integration pages (describing how to use Inspiration in a class), or one of each.
Some students worried that all the pages were taken up for what they wanted to do. To clarify, only one group can do a description page on a technology. For example, if someone else is explaining Excel, what it is, and so forth--why would you want to do that? There's only so much you can say. However, there are hundreds of different ways to apply Excel to school situations. So there could be hundreds of Excel Integration pages. If someone is already doing an Excel integration page, and you want to, just make a new link to a new page and do it!
Remember that if you don't understand wikis (for example, you don't know what I was talking about when I said, "make a new page"), then go to the wiki sandbox and learn! Here's the link to the sandbox: http://ipt.byu.edu/~wiki/28x/Main/WikiSandbox
Go there and at the bottom of the screen are some brief directions on how to write and create in wiki. I'll give only one tip here. If, when you're typing, you mash two words together, like this: "RickWest," it will create a new page and link to that page. It's that easy!
Ask and ye shall receive ...
Remember how a week ago the question was brought up in class why when you read something in Bloglines, it disappears when you go back there? I explained that this is a good feature to keep only new, unread stuff in your aggregator so you don't fill it up with a bunch of old stuff. But I agree there are times when you want to save something for later, and not have it immediately disappear when you log out.
Now you can do something about it.
Bloglines just introduced a new feature tonight that you should be able to read about the next time you log into Bloglines. To quote them:
"When reading your feeds, at the bottom of each entry is a checkbox labeled Keep New. Check it and that entry is marked unread, and will stay that way until you uncheck the box. This is useful for entries that you decide you don't have time to read right now, but that you don't want to save in your Clippings folder. You can also use the mark all new link that appears at the top of each feed in the right pane when reading subscriptions to reset all the currently displayed items to unread."
So if you check this box, it will not erase a post you want to go back and reread later. Too cool! That's what I love about Bloglines. There are many different brands of aggregators out there, but Bloglines is continually trying to fix things to make their customers happy.
Now you can do something about it.
Bloglines just introduced a new feature tonight that you should be able to read about the next time you log into Bloglines. To quote them:
"When reading your feeds, at the bottom of each entry is a checkbox labeled Keep New. Check it and that entry is marked unread, and will stay that way until you uncheck the box. This is useful for entries that you decide you don't have time to read right now, but that you don't want to save in your Clippings folder. You can also use the mark all new link that appears at the top of each feed in the right pane when reading subscriptions to reset all the currently displayed items to unread."
So if you check this box, it will not erase a post you want to go back and reread later. Too cool! That's what I love about Bloglines. There are many different brands of aggregators out there, but Bloglines is continually trying to fix things to make their customers happy.
Tuesday, September 21, 2004
Your homework groups
One of the crazy curveballs I threw at you this week (once again, apologies for introducing so many new things this week) were new groups. Let me explain:
- You have blogging groups to share ideas. You did one homework assignment in blogging groups, this was the Intro to Tech Integration assignment. You will do no more homework assignments in your blogging groups. You should still read each other's blogs and comment to each other, but you will not be doing homework together.
- You have homework groups. Many of the assignments in this class are group-based projects. We do this because we know many of the assignments can be complicated, and the groups are there to share the workload and help each other out so that you are not so overwhelmed. We also agree with Vygotsky, Leve, Wenger, Engestrom, and other learning theorists who believe you learn more effectively in social situations. We have learned by experience that groups of 2-4 work best. It is important to work well in your group and to communicate often because you will do several assignments together.
Here are your homework groups for the rest of the semester. I really hate my naming scheme, and I'm sure you do to. If you want to have a unique name for your group, rather than "Science 2.1" then tell me what you want to call yourselves. I've had some fun groups in my classes before, from the Spongebobs to the Gryffindors.
Megan A./Nicole K./Elaine T.
Science 2.1
Memorie D./Sarah E./Rosie
Science 2.2
Carla Goodman/Benjamin Sheldon
Science 3
Jill S./Matthew Z./J'Nette N./Rachel F.
English 4.1
Jonathan B./Hayley B./Elisa Findlay
English 4.2
Joseph G./Camille M./Natalie C.
English 5.1
Tiffany M./Thomas Jared R./Danielle S.
English 5.2
Bonnie S./Caroline U./Fran Masino
History/Social Sciences/Geography (HSG) 6.1
Molly B./Jeremy J./Lindsay B.
HSG 6.2
Amy E./Savanna W./Emily D.
Languages
Roxana L./Mary M./Alise P./Elaine D.
Health/Home Ec/Family and Consumer Sciences (HHF) 8.1
Lindsay B./Jamie C./Rachelle D./Jessica M
HHF 8.2
Sarah B./Erin C./Elisa F.
- You have blogging groups to share ideas. You did one homework assignment in blogging groups, this was the Intro to Tech Integration assignment. You will do no more homework assignments in your blogging groups. You should still read each other's blogs and comment to each other, but you will not be doing homework together.
- You have homework groups. Many of the assignments in this class are group-based projects. We do this because we know many of the assignments can be complicated, and the groups are there to share the workload and help each other out so that you are not so overwhelmed. We also agree with Vygotsky, Leve, Wenger, Engestrom, and other learning theorists who believe you learn more effectively in social situations. We have learned by experience that groups of 2-4 work best. It is important to work well in your group and to communicate often because you will do several assignments together.
Here are your homework groups for the rest of the semester. I really hate my naming scheme, and I'm sure you do to. If you want to have a unique name for your group, rather than "Science 2.1" then tell me what you want to call yourselves. I've had some fun groups in my classes before, from the Spongebobs to the Gryffindors.
Homework Groups
Dance
Megan A./Nicole K./Elaine T.
Science 2.1
Memorie D./Sarah E./Rosie
Science 2.2
Carla Goodman/Benjamin Sheldon
Science 3
Jill S./Matthew Z./J'Nette N./Rachel F.
English 4.1
Jonathan B./Hayley B./Elisa Findlay
English 4.2
Joseph G./Camille M./Natalie C.
English 5.1
Tiffany M./Thomas Jared R./Danielle S.
English 5.2
Bonnie S./Caroline U./Fran Masino
History/Social Sciences/Geography (HSG) 6.1
Molly B./Jeremy J./Lindsay B.
HSG 6.2
Amy E./Savanna W./Emily D.
Languages
Roxana L./Mary M./Alise P./Elaine D.
Health/Home Ec/Family and Consumer Sciences (HHF) 8.1
Lindsay B./Jamie C./Rachelle D./Jessica M
HHF 8.2
Sarah B./Erin C./Elisa F.
Monday, September 20, 2004
This week's assignments
Whew! Today was definitely a cognitive overload day. I could tell it on your faces, and I'll definitely be adjusting the schedule for the future. Sorry about that everyone--what was I thinking introducing html AND wikis in the same week?
The consolation to you should be that while the cognitive load is very heavy this week (i.e. there is a big learning curve this week for what we're doing), the actual workload is light. The assignments really are easy. So spend your homework time trying to figure out how to work a Wiki and how to do your blogrolls (if you haven't).
To summarize, there are two things due this week. I won't describe the assignments in detail because we've described them in detail on the assignment pages. If you have questions, however, write them as comments here and I will answer them within 24 hours.
Due this week:
1) Blogrolls — Post your digital resources to your blogrolls so your blogging buddies can see the sources you've found. The purpose of this assignment is also to get your feet briefly wet in HTML: what it looks like and how to write in this language. You should have done most of this in class.
2) Outline your wiki pages — Learn how to wiki, what the wiki language is (which is different from html), and decide as a group what wiki pages you will do. This is described, again, in much more detail on the assignment page. The important thing that I think lacked in many groups today is you didn't coordinate when you would meet, or call, or email, or whatever to set this up. You have to somehow communicate as a group and decide what wiki pages you want to do, and outline them very briefly on our class wiki website.
BTW- Many of you, it seemed, did not even look at the assignment page for the intro to technology integration assignment. How come? We basically gave you the specifics on how to do the assignment and get your points. We do that each week, so I encourage you to follow the rubric and you will probably have fewer questions and more points.
Double BTW — I have office hours but nobody ever comes! I can visit with students Mondays from noon to 2 p.m. or Wednesdays from noon to 2 p.m. All I ask is that you email me beforehand and then I'll meet you in the computer lab. If those times don't work, suggest another day and I'll meet you then, if I can. I want to help you this week because I know there was a lot of confusion, so just email me or post a question on my blog and I'll help you, if I can.
The consolation to you should be that while the cognitive load is very heavy this week (i.e. there is a big learning curve this week for what we're doing), the actual workload is light. The assignments really are easy. So spend your homework time trying to figure out how to work a Wiki and how to do your blogrolls (if you haven't).
To summarize, there are two things due this week. I won't describe the assignments in detail because we've described them in detail on the assignment pages. If you have questions, however, write them as comments here and I will answer them within 24 hours.
Due this week:
1) Blogrolls — Post your digital resources to your blogrolls so your blogging buddies can see the sources you've found. The purpose of this assignment is also to get your feet briefly wet in HTML: what it looks like and how to write in this language. You should have done most of this in class.
2) Outline your wiki pages — Learn how to wiki, what the wiki language is (which is different from html), and decide as a group what wiki pages you will do. This is described, again, in much more detail on the assignment page. The important thing that I think lacked in many groups today is you didn't coordinate when you would meet, or call, or email, or whatever to set this up. You have to somehow communicate as a group and decide what wiki pages you want to do, and outline them very briefly on our class wiki website.
BTW- Many of you, it seemed, did not even look at the assignment page for the intro to technology integration assignment. How come? We basically gave you the specifics on how to do the assignment and get your points. We do that each week, so I encourage you to follow the rubric and you will probably have fewer questions and more points.
Double BTW — I have office hours but nobody ever comes! I can visit with students Mondays from noon to 2 p.m. or Wednesdays from noon to 2 p.m. All I ask is that you email me beforehand and then I'll meet you in the computer lab. If those times don't work, suggest another day and I'll meet you then, if I can. I want to help you this week because I know there was a lot of confusion, so just email me or post a question on my blog and I'll help you, if I can.
What good technology integration is
Thank you all for your insightful ideas about what constitutes good technology integration that you posted last week. We are grading the intro to technology integration assignment still, but here is my list of Principles for Good Technology Integration, gleaned from all of your postings (yes, I read everybody's "rules"). This might be worth clipping and saving and then pulling out to remind yourself every summer before you charge into a new school year.
I've linked to each blog that provided the idea. If none of your ideas are listed here, don't be disappointed. Many people had the same good idea, but I only linked to one student, just because it was easier.
Principles for Good Technology Integration
I've linked to each blog that provided the idea. If none of your ideas are listed here, don't be disappointed. Many people had the same good idea, but I only linked to one student, just because it was easier.
Principles for Good Technology Integration
- Always keep trying new things, do not remain stagnant on your own techniques. Keep integrating new tools every year.
- Integration should help students prepare for the workforce by educating them in adapting to new technologies
- Technology integration should enhance cognitive learning through added interaction among students and applying knowledge to create something using technology
- Technology should help create higher thinking skills and critical analysis
- Students should be the main users of the technology (as opposed to the teacher); teachers should be available to give examples and guide the students, but students will learn (the technology and the subject) best if they are the primary users of the technology.
- Teachers should understand the subject-matter to be taught, as well as the technology/programs being used before they attempt teaching
- Be creative- enough powerpoints, already!
- I think all of us agree it is most important that the technology that we use has to increase the child's learning. It can't be a hinderance to the learning process.
- Technology should understand that some students won't respond to technology and computers and should provide a variety of learning activities at all times.
- Assess students’ acheivments and what they are learning through a variety of technology techniques.
- A tool is only as good as the person behind it - technology should be used to help the students think, not to avoid thinking
- Technology should be interactive: students should be able to respond to the material.
- Just because a technological tool is there, doesn't necessarily mean that it adds to the educational experience
- As an educator, take advantage of every opportunity to learn more; study different techologies, improve your own skills, and constantly work to get better
- Using tehnology should not replace the need for improvement or interaction from the actual teacher
- Technology should help students see and experience the real world that a traditional classroom setting cannot provide by helping students construct knowledge instead of just reproducing it
- Activities involving technology should build on what the students already know so that they can see its relevance and application, but it should also offer something they wouldn't get from regular classroom activities in order to expand their learning experience
Friday, September 17, 2004
About the digital resources assignment
At least one student wondered whether you were supposed to turn in your homework this week as a posting on your blog. You know, that probably would have been a good idea ... if I had thought of it! In past semesters we have always had students turn the assignment into Blackboard, and I guess I just didn't think about changing that. Maybe next time I will.
But for THIS WEEK'S ASSIGNMENT, turn it into blackboard, just so that everyone does the same thing and we're uniform. Here's how:
Go to the assignment page if you haven't yet.
Download the template.
When you've filled out the template, post it in Blackboard under the "digital resources" assignment. It may be near the bottom until I get a chance to move it to the top.
Any questions? Post them as comments to this post.
But for THIS WEEK'S ASSIGNMENT, turn it into blackboard, just so that everyone does the same thing and we're uniform. Here's how:
Go to the assignment page if you haven't yet.
Download the template.
When you've filled out the template, post it in Blackboard under the "digital resources" assignment. It may be near the bottom until I get a chance to move it to the top.
Any questions? Post them as comments to this post.
How technology can help the disabled
We spend most of the time in class talking about how technology can help regular learners, but there will probably come a time when you will have a disabled student of some sort in your class, whether that disability is physical or even a learning disability. There are many kinds of technology that assist the disabled to do many of the things we take for granted. These are often called "assistive technologies." I heard about one such technology today. It's called a Nouse, and it's like a computer mouse but is steered by your nose and eyelids. This is of course very useful for people who can't use their hands. There are other technologies too, and I even heard about an email program for special needs students, who normally can't type or sometimes read. In this program, they select pictures--kind of like emoticons -- to express what they are feeling at the moment, and they push a button to email these pictures to another person. I had another student last semester who created a simple learning game using PowerPoint that teaches letters to severely mentally handicapped students.
About students with learning disabilities. I have a hunch, but I'd need to do some research to see if this has been tested, that students with ADD or ADHD difficulties might do better with technology assignments than regular assignments. I have had some personal difficulties with my attention span and I've found that having a laptop with me in class gives me something to do with my hands ... and I actually learn a lot more from my professors. I used to sleep in almost all of my classes, and teachers probably thought I was being disrespectful, but I couldn't help it. Now I work on my laptop, and it helps me stay awake and listen better.
I won't talk much about assistive technology in this class because we're more focused on other things. But you should be aware of the possibilities and if you ever have a student with special needs, there might be a way some kind of technology could help you teach that student.
About students with learning disabilities. I have a hunch, but I'd need to do some research to see if this has been tested, that students with ADD or ADHD difficulties might do better with technology assignments than regular assignments. I have had some personal difficulties with my attention span and I've found that having a laptop with me in class gives me something to do with my hands ... and I actually learn a lot more from my professors. I used to sleep in almost all of my classes, and teachers probably thought I was being disrespectful, but I couldn't help it. Now I work on my laptop, and it helps me stay awake and listen better.
I won't talk much about assistive technology in this class because we're more focused on other things. But you should be aware of the possibilities and if you ever have a student with special needs, there might be a way some kind of technology could help you teach that student.
Is student agency a good thing?
Hmmm, there's been some good posts today. I'll pick out one that some of you may be interested in. Rosie refers to a report by KSL that there is a new charter school in Salt Lake that gives students complete freedom and agency to choose their educational experience. They decide what subjects to study, and how to study them.
Rosie was unsure of what to think about this and said:
"I have mixed feelings. I think that it is good to give students the opprotunity to send time on things that they enjoy and to allow them to learn the things that interest them. However, its kind of scary too. No structure at all could lead to a lack of learning."
I also have mixed feelings, however I think there should be more freedom than there is now in public education. Rosie critiques this new charter school by saying that "These student may end up not learning anything because they don't feel like it." But to be honest, these students won't learn much in traditional schools either if they don't feel like it. I guess that's one plus for more student agency and choice: people tend to learn when they are motivated, and they are motivated when they are learning things that are important to them. So why not give students some more freedom? Let them have a little more leeway to choose what they want to learn, and they might be more self-motivated and be better students.
Now, after saying that, I do agree with Rosie that some structure is good, and we do have to encourage students to get a well-rounded education, or else they'll learn a lot of one thing and not much of anything else. But perhaps a little more choice and agency than is currently allowed in schools would be a good thing?
Now to tie this to technology. I believe technology can give students that freedom to explore, experiment, participate, and choose topics of study. What do you think? How could technology give students some of that freedom?
Rosie was unsure of what to think about this and said:
"I have mixed feelings. I think that it is good to give students the opprotunity to send time on things that they enjoy and to allow them to learn the things that interest them. However, its kind of scary too. No structure at all could lead to a lack of learning."
I also have mixed feelings, however I think there should be more freedom than there is now in public education. Rosie critiques this new charter school by saying that "These student may end up not learning anything because they don't feel like it." But to be honest, these students won't learn much in traditional schools either if they don't feel like it. I guess that's one plus for more student agency and choice: people tend to learn when they are motivated, and they are motivated when they are learning things that are important to them. So why not give students some more freedom? Let them have a little more leeway to choose what they want to learn, and they might be more self-motivated and be better students.
Now, after saying that, I do agree with Rosie that some structure is good, and we do have to encourage students to get a well-rounded education, or else they'll learn a lot of one thing and not much of anything else. But perhaps a little more choice and agency than is currently allowed in schools would be a good thing?
Now to tie this to technology. I believe technology can give students that freedom to explore, experiment, participate, and choose topics of study. What do you think? How could technology give students some of that freedom?
Thursday, September 16, 2004
An option for digital resources assignment
BTW- Here's an option for the digital resources assignment, even though it doesn't talk about it on the assignment page: You can count an educational weblog or an rss/atom feed as one of your digital resources. Why not? Some of my best digital resources that I use weekly, even daily, as a teacher are weblogs from really great sources that have really good ideas.
Remember that you'll have to establish the credibility of the blog. Normally website credibility is established when you look for things like government sites, non-profit organization sites, sites by trusted authorities, etc. Weblogs are different because most weblogs are run by normal people. So I'm thinking you could probably justify a blog as a good digital resource if you can explain to me why:
1) It is useful
2) you trust the ideas from this person
3) you would read it often enough to gain value from it
4) you would use the source as a teacher
You might also look for whether the person quotes other sources or is quoted himself, and what kinds of conversation does he/she have on the blog? A blog that is widely read by many people and has many people commenting on it is probably a good blog .
I know what you're thinking, and no, the Dilbert feed I showed you does not count as an educational resource! :-)
Have fun exploring! There are many good thinkers out there and many of them have weblogs!
Remember that you'll have to establish the credibility of the blog. Normally website credibility is established when you look for things like government sites, non-profit organization sites, sites by trusted authorities, etc. Weblogs are different because most weblogs are run by normal people. So I'm thinking you could probably justify a blog as a good digital resource if you can explain to me why:
1) It is useful
2) you trust the ideas from this person
3) you would read it often enough to gain value from it
4) you would use the source as a teacher
You might also look for whether the person quotes other sources or is quoted himself, and what kinds of conversation does he/she have on the blog? A blog that is widely read by many people and has many people commenting on it is probably a good blog .
I know what you're thinking, and no, the Dilbert feed I showed you does not count as an educational resource! :-)
Have fun exploring! There are many good thinkers out there and many of them have weblogs!
Question: How do I add links to posts?
Here's a question emailed to me that I thought others might have too:
"I have not figured out how to make links to stuff yet."
Here's my answer:
"The biggest key to being able to put links into a post is to use MOZILLA as your browser (it is on all of the computers in the TLSC computer lab and can be downloaded for free for your home computer at mozilla.org). When you are using Mozilla instead of Explorer, there are some cool buttons in blogger that help you edit your post, for example, you can change colors, add links, bold or italicize words, and do bulleted lists, etc. For some weird reason, those options are not in Explorer as far as we can tell.
Besides, Mozilla is a safer, more secure browser anyway and you'll get less spyware and adware with Mozilla."
Just to show you want you can do if you blog in Mozilla, here's some examples (you won't see these in your Bloglines aggregator. You'll have to actually go to my blog to see them):
You can bold, italicize, put in links, and change text color.
You can also add pictures, but you need to do a few extra steps that I won't explain here. If you want to learn how to add pictures to your posts, Blogger has some help pages, or you can meet with me sometime and I'll show you how!
"I have not figured out how to make links to stuff yet."
Here's my answer:
"The biggest key to being able to put links into a post is to use MOZILLA as your browser (it is on all of the computers in the TLSC computer lab and can be downloaded for free for your home computer at mozilla.org). When you are using Mozilla instead of Explorer, there are some cool buttons in blogger that help you edit your post, for example, you can change colors, add links, bold or italicize words, and do bulleted lists, etc. For some weird reason, those options are not in Explorer as far as we can tell.
Besides, Mozilla is a safer, more secure browser anyway and you'll get less spyware and adware with Mozilla."
Just to show you want you can do if you blog in Mozilla, here's some examples (you won't see these in your Bloglines aggregator. You'll have to actually go to my blog to see them):
You can bold, italicize, put in links, and change text color.
Center text
- bullet text
- number text
or indent quotes
You can also add pictures, but you need to do a few extra steps that I won't explain here. If you want to learn how to add pictures to your posts, Blogger has some help pages, or you can meet with me sometime and I'll show you how!
Intro Survey is graded
I will try to always post when I am done grading an assignment so you can check your grades. I just graded the intro survey assignment. If you did it, you got full credit. And thank you to most of you for being willing to let us use your data in the research study! Four students elected not to let us use this data, which is fine, but they then forgot to put their names on the survey. Without their names, we can't give them credit for doing it (the names wouldn't be used in our research anyway--they are strictly for us to give you points for doing the survey). Anyway, if any of those students are in my class, or if anybody else did the survey and did not get credit, email me.
You can check your grades by going to Blackboard.
One last note: Emily Day, are you signed up for our class? I thought you were, but you didn't show up in my Blackboard gradebook so I couldn't give you credit.
You can check your grades by going to Blackboard.
One last note: Emily Day, are you signed up for our class? I thought you were, but you didn't show up in my Blackboard gradebook so I couldn't give you credit.
Tuesday, September 14, 2004
Interesting posts for Sept. 14
Hey gang, here's some of the interesting posts I read this last week. These are not necessarily the best posts, because it's just my opinion of what jumped out to me. But I thought I'd share the ones that you might not have read that I have enjoyed.
Carla's blog, Surprise!, is a great place to have a good discussion. She started a discussion on stem cell research and then this week posted this:
At least for this class, hopefully your blogging buddies will be reading. After that, who knows?
"Luma" (still my favorite screen name :-) had a thoughtful response to the Mindtools article by David Jonassen that we all scanned for last week's assignment. In the article, Jonassen says that:
Here's some possible questions for discussion:
Carla's blog, Surprise!, is a great place to have a good discussion. She started a discussion on stem cell research and then this week posted this:
"Houston has purposed (and really wants to) build a school just for immigrants. They have a large group of students whose needs are not being met by the traditional school system, and so they want to make a school with the flexibility and focus that immigrant students need. More info on CNN: http://www.cnn.com/2004/EDUCATION/09/08/immigrant.school.ap/index.htmlMegan probably has the same thought many of you do:
What do you think? Will this meet the need or will it further isolate ethnicities?"
"Well, that is my post for today. No one has come and read any of my posts so far so it kind of feels like I am just talking to myself. I hope that someone eventually checks this out! Until next time...."I commented that at least I am reading her blog (and enjoying it too--she's putting some personality into it, which is nice). Blogging brings up an interesting point about audience. It's out there on the Internet, and you never know who might be reading you--even if they never comment on your blog. I posted a comment similar to Megan's on my other blog, wondering if anybody was reading my blog, and a lady from Melbourne Australia said she was reading it -- and enjoyed it! Who else could be reading, and we don't know? I posted my thoughts on my other blog about how just the potential of having an audience, even if we don't know how big that audience may be, forces me to be more thoughtful and careful about what I say.
At least for this class, hopefully your blogging buddies will be reading. After that, who knows?
"Luma" (still my favorite screen name :-) had a thoughtful response to the Mindtools article by David Jonassen that we all scanned for last week's assignment. In the article, Jonassen says that:
"When learners use computers as partners, they off-load some of the unproductive memorizing tasks to the computer, allowing the learner to think more productively."Luma disagreed with his evaluation of memorizing as "unproductive." Her reasoning is that
"Although memorizing often seems like busywork, it is very necessary in education. There is no way to get along without at least a few rudimentary memorization skills. The very ability to read comes from memorizing letters, combinations, and sounds. How much longer and more difficult will homework assignments take if students are not required to memorize? Students would be constantly looking up information that should be found in the cannon of knowledge of an educated person."I thought she had a great point, and there is power in being able to quote or recall information from memory, but I responded with the reasoning from the other side of the fence:
"This is actually heavily debated in education right now. Do we teach students to "know" things by having them memorize procedures and facts, or do we help them learn how to "do" things with knowledge that is stored in computers or databases? For example, should students have to memorize calculus equations, or simply know what the theories are and how to apply the correct equation to the correct situation?"I'd like us as a class to discuss this further. And don't be afraid to share your opinion, even if it's different from mine. I'm still developing my ideas and like to hear your perspectives!
Here's some possible questions for discussion:
- Do you agree with Jonassen that technology should be used as mindtools and not for drill-and-practice, memorization, etc.?
- What kinds of learning and knowledge do our students need to learn the most?
- Should we have students memorize facts, numbers, formulas, etc.?
- How much memorizing should we do and how much other types of learning should we encourage?
BYU vs. Stanford
We had a lively discussion last week after the BYU game, so I'll post another discussion about last week's game. This is totally off-topic, so if football doesn't interest you, skip this post!
I almost didn't want to post after last week's game. What is there to say? It seems that BYU football just isn't as much fun anymore. It used to be that even if they lost, you were glued to your seat, mostly because we had such explosive offenses that you never knew that the game was really over. I mean, the Miracle Bowl could ALWAYS happen with old BYU offenses. It just doesn't seem that we have that offensive swagger anymore.
Really, our stats were almost identical to Stanford's. What was the difference? Mistakes. Interceptions, Fumbles, Penalties, Missed assignments, Poor decisions. We really weren't that overmatched, and Jason Beck didn't do that bad--we just had too many mistakes.
Go ahead and post your thoughts--I want to hear them! However, remember to be nice. Anybody could be reading this. Critique the game and the team, but let's not bash individuals.
I almost didn't want to post after last week's game. What is there to say? It seems that BYU football just isn't as much fun anymore. It used to be that even if they lost, you were glued to your seat, mostly because we had such explosive offenses that you never knew that the game was really over. I mean, the Miracle Bowl could ALWAYS happen with old BYU offenses. It just doesn't seem that we have that offensive swagger anymore.
Really, our stats were almost identical to Stanford's. What was the difference? Mistakes. Interceptions, Fumbles, Penalties, Missed assignments, Poor decisions. We really weren't that overmatched, and Jason Beck didn't do that bad--we just had too many mistakes.
Go ahead and post your thoughts--I want to hear them! However, remember to be nice. Anybody could be reading this. Critique the game and the team, but let's not bash individuals.
Cool blogging tip
Katy from another section of IPT 286 found a great way to expand your blogging circle. She writes:
BTW - if you find a great blogging tip or feed from a good blog, or if you hear about a great new technology that you think we might be useful in, post it on your blog and spread the news!
"If you fill out your extended profile, you can list your interests and hobbies. I did this, and then viewed my updated profile. It sets apart your interests and highlights and underlines them. If you click on them, then it brings up every other blog that has the same interest as you listed. Thus you can find people from all around the world with the same interests as you"Cool Katy, thanks!
BTW - if you find a great blogging tip or feed from a good blog, or if you hear about a great new technology that you think we might be useful in, post it on your blog and spread the news!
Monday, September 13, 2004
Discussing digital resources
In a previous post, I explained what you needed to do for this week's assignment. In this post, I'd like to discuss a little why digital resources are so important. Ideally, we'd hold this discussion in class. I'd usually pair you up, you'd discuss things as a pair, and then we'd share our ideas with the rest. We'll have to do the best we can online, and I hope many of you share your ideas as comments to this post, or as posts on your own blogs.
Why do we want you to learn how to find things on the Internet? Doesn't everyone know how to do that already? Yeah, but like I mentioned in class today, there is too much information out there in the world. The problem is many don't know how to use it. The people who really know how to find good, useful, and credible websites fast are usually much more productive than the rest of us. In an article called "The ABCs of Website Evaluation," Kathleen Schrock gives 26 (one for every letter of the alphabet) criteria for evaluating websites. She talks about criteria such as authority (is it a credible author?), dates (is it current?), bias (why was this site created?), and citations (does it have them?). She also gives the 5 Ws for evaluating websites:
Here's the discussion questions I'd like to ask you, and I hope you'll answer!
Why do we want you to learn how to find things on the Internet? Doesn't everyone know how to do that already? Yeah, but like I mentioned in class today, there is too much information out there in the world. The problem is many don't know how to use it. The people who really know how to find good, useful, and credible websites fast are usually much more productive than the rest of us. In an article called "The ABCs of Website Evaluation," Kathleen Schrock gives 26 (one for every letter of the alphabet) criteria for evaluating websites. She talks about criteria such as authority (is it a credible author?), dates (is it current?), bias (why was this site created?), and citations (does it have them?). She also gives the 5 Ws for evaluating websites:
- Who wrote this material and put this website together? Are they credible sources?
- What is the purpose of this site?
- When was this site put together and last updated?
- Where does this information come from?
- Why is it useful to me?
Here's the discussion questions I'd like to ask you, and I hope you'll answer!
- How do you know a good website from a not so good one? What do you look for?
- What types of websites are the BEST ones for helping you as a teacher?
- What search techniques do you have for helping you find good material in a web search?
- How could we teach our students how to find information quickly and recognize good information when they see it?
Digital Resources assignment - due Sept. 20
Well gang, I am sorry we ran out of time before we fully discussed this week's assignment. I'm used to teaching IPT 287--a 2-credit class. I'll try to manage class time better!
Because I didn't get to explain the assignment in class, I'll do so here. If you have questions, you can post them as a comment and we can carry on a Q and A here on my blog.
First off, the direct link to the assignment is right here. However, you can always get it from the "calendar" or "assignments" link on the right of my blog. You can read the details on the assignment page, but here's the brief low-down:
Purpose: Find a lesson plan and two good educational digital resources (with the emphasis on good).
How:
1. Go to uen.org and find the standards for your teaching emphasis.
2. Pick a standard and find a lesson plan to teach that standard
3. Pick another (or the same) standard and find two educational websites that would help you teach that standard
4. Post your Word document to BLACKBOARD as an attachment to a post in the discussion forum called "Digital Resources."
Like I said, there's more detail on the assignment page.
Once you've found your digital resources, you need to evaluate them and explain why they are good resources using the template we've created for you. On the template, it asks you to what category of educational website your resource belongs to. These were the papers I had available for you in class. You can also download these 11 categories of Educational Websites here. I attended a conference just a week ago where Trey Martindale, a blogger himself, explained these categories. He admits that many really good websites fit into multiple categories, so if the digital resources you find fit into multiple categories too, that's fine--just explain your reasoning.
Trey describes the 11 types of educational websites in the article you can download, but it might still be helpful to get a second take on it, so here's my stab at explaining the categories:
1. Instructional
A website with a learning activity that asks a student to do something, has specific instructional goals, and a way to assess or give feedback on the student's performance.
2. Learning Activity
A website similar to instructional sites, but perhaps lacking the goals or assessment aspects.
3. Content Collection
A popular form of website that simply has a bunch of material on one subject. Example: A website on Shakespeare that has tons of stuff on good ol' Will.
4. List of Links
A website that has the main purpose of providing links to other great websites.
5. Reference/Archive/News/Database (RAND)
A website that is a reference tool, such as an online dictionary, encyclopedia, or the like. Different than content collection because it has information on many subjects and not just one.
6. Teacher and Parent Resouces
A website geared not towards students, but those who teach them.
7. Shared Experience
Websites where students can experience things togethers, such as virtual tours.
8. Personal Expression and Interpersonal Interaction (PEII)
Websites that allow people to interact, express themselves, and communicate.
9. Informal education.
Websites not meant to be educational, but which have educational components. For example the Hogle Zoo probably has material on its website that would be great for elementary lessons.
10. Research and Service Organizations and Projects (RSOP - boy you gotta love his acronomyms, huh?)
Websites that are organized as part of some massive research project
11. Commercial. Example is Microsoft's education page.
Go forth and conquer!
Because I didn't get to explain the assignment in class, I'll do so here. If you have questions, you can post them as a comment and we can carry on a Q and A here on my blog.
First off, the direct link to the assignment is right here. However, you can always get it from the "calendar" or "assignments" link on the right of my blog. You can read the details on the assignment page, but here's the brief low-down:
Purpose: Find a lesson plan and two good educational digital resources (with the emphasis on good).
How:
1. Go to uen.org and find the standards for your teaching emphasis.
2. Pick a standard and find a lesson plan to teach that standard
3. Pick another (or the same) standard and find two educational websites that would help you teach that standard
4. Post your Word document to BLACKBOARD as an attachment to a post in the discussion forum called "Digital Resources."
Like I said, there's more detail on the assignment page.
Once you've found your digital resources, you need to evaluate them and explain why they are good resources using the template we've created for you. On the template, it asks you to what category of educational website your resource belongs to. These were the papers I had available for you in class. You can also download these 11 categories of Educational Websites here. I attended a conference just a week ago where Trey Martindale, a blogger himself, explained these categories. He admits that many really good websites fit into multiple categories, so if the digital resources you find fit into multiple categories too, that's fine--just explain your reasoning.
Trey describes the 11 types of educational websites in the article you can download, but it might still be helpful to get a second take on it, so here's my stab at explaining the categories:
1. Instructional
A website with a learning activity that asks a student to do something, has specific instructional goals, and a way to assess or give feedback on the student's performance.
2. Learning Activity
A website similar to instructional sites, but perhaps lacking the goals or assessment aspects.
3. Content Collection
A popular form of website that simply has a bunch of material on one subject. Example: A website on Shakespeare that has tons of stuff on good ol' Will.
4. List of Links
A website that has the main purpose of providing links to other great websites.
5. Reference/Archive/News/Database (RAND)
A website that is a reference tool, such as an online dictionary, encyclopedia, or the like. Different than content collection because it has information on many subjects and not just one.
6. Teacher and Parent Resouces
A website geared not towards students, but those who teach them.
7. Shared Experience
Websites where students can experience things togethers, such as virtual tours.
8. Personal Expression and Interpersonal Interaction (PEII)
Websites that allow people to interact, express themselves, and communicate.
9. Informal education.
Websites not meant to be educational, but which have educational components. For example the Hogle Zoo probably has material on its website that would be great for elementary lessons.
10. Research and Service Organizations and Projects (RSOP - boy you gotta love his acronomyms, huh?)
Websites that are organized as part of some massive research project
11. Commercial. Example is Microsoft's education page.
Go forth and conquer!
A lesson learned from the music industry
An interesting observation was made by Timothy on Slashdot recently. Have you noticed that for the first time, the next big thing in the music industry is NOT better quality but better mobility? In the past, the next big thing in music has always been more Hi-Fi, better sound, higher fidelity. Now the future is mp3, which is poorer quality than the current CDs, but is a whole lot easier, more mobile, and more convenient.
Can we learn something from the music industry about using technology in education? I think we can. I think we often think we need BETTER technology, MORE RAM, MORE memory, FASTER processors, the MOST RECENT softwares, BIGGEST upgrades, and so on and so forth. Many times teachers complain that they can't integrate technology into their teaching because their school doesn't have enough money. But it seems that the technologies that sometimes make the biggest impacts on education are the small ones that are so ubiquitous, so transparent, so assimilated into our society that everybody already has these technologies and knows how to use them.
For example, which technologies are used the most in education today? Video. Internet. Audio. Word processing. Why? Because these are easy technologies to use and most students already know how to use them so we don't have to teach them.
What will be the easy, simple, and everybody-has-one technology of tomorrow? Can we start planning how to use those technologies in the schools?
This also ties back into our laptop discussion we had last week. Many students posted that having laptops for every student was a bad idea because of cost factors. So what kinds of technologies are so cheap, simple, and available to everyone that we CAN expect most students to already have them and to know how to use them?
Can we learn something from the music industry about using technology in education? I think we can. I think we often think we need BETTER technology, MORE RAM, MORE memory, FASTER processors, the MOST RECENT softwares, BIGGEST upgrades, and so on and so forth. Many times teachers complain that they can't integrate technology into their teaching because their school doesn't have enough money. But it seems that the technologies that sometimes make the biggest impacts on education are the small ones that are so ubiquitous, so transparent, so assimilated into our society that everybody already has these technologies and knows how to use them.
For example, which technologies are used the most in education today? Video. Internet. Audio. Word processing. Why? Because these are easy technologies to use and most students already know how to use them so we don't have to teach them.
What will be the easy, simple, and everybody-has-one technology of tomorrow? Can we start planning how to use those technologies in the schools?
This also ties back into our laptop discussion we had last week. Many students posted that having laptops for every student was a bad idea because of cost factors. So what kinds of technologies are so cheap, simple, and available to everyone that we CAN expect most students to already have them and to know how to use them?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)